Microbicidal composition

ABSTRACT

An aqueous microbicidal composition having two components. The first component is a nonionic surfactant with structure: R 2 O(CH 2 CH(CH 3 )O) 3 (CH 2 CH 2 O) 5 H, where R 2  is a mixture of C 8 -C 14  linear alkyl groups. The second component is a benzoate or sorbate salt. The weight ratio of the nonionic surfactant to the benzoate or sorbate salt is from 1:0.12 to 1:109.7646.

This invention relates to microbicidal compositions containing benzoate or sorbate and a surfactant.

A composition containing 5-chloro-2-methylisothiazolin-3-one, 2-methylisothiazolin-3-one and a nonionic dispersant is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,295,932. The composition contains a 3:1 mixture of 5-chloro-2-methylisothiazolin-3-one and 2-methylisothiazolin-3-one, and a copolymer of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide which appears to have the same composition as PLURONIC L61 or TERGITOL L61 dispersant. However, there is a need for combinations of microbicides having synergistic activity against various strains of microorganisms to provide effective control of the microorganisms. Moreover, there is a need for such combinations containing lower levels of individual microbicides for environmental and economic benefit. The problem addressed by this invention is to provide such synergistic combinations of microbicides.

STATEMENT OF THE INVENTION

The present invention is directed to a synergistic microbicidal composition comprising: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate or sorbate salt is from 1:0.12 to 1:109.7646.

The present invention is further directed to a synergistic microbicidal composition comprising: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate salt is from 1:3.6010 to 1:109.7646 and a ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:0.06 to 1:0.5714 or 1:2.3990 to 1:109.7646.

The present invention is further directed to a synergistic microbicidal composition comprising: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R¹O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₅(CH₂CH₂O)₉H

where R¹ is a C₈ alkyl group; and (b) a sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:0.1 to 1:0.9143.

The present invention is further directed to methods for inhibiting the growth of microorganisms in aqueous media by adding to an aqueous medium a nonionic surfactant as described herein and a benzoate or sorbate salt in the ratios described herein.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

As used herein, the following terms have the designated definitions, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. The term “microbicide” refers to a compound capable of inhibiting the growth of or controlling the growth of microorganisms; microbicides include bactericides, fungicides and algaecides. The term “microorganism” includes, for example, fungi (such as yeast and mold), bacteria and algae. The following abbreviations are used throughout the specification: ppm=parts per million by weight (weight/weight), mL=milliliter. Unless otherwise specified, temperatures are in degrees centigrade (° C.), references to percentages are percentages by weight (wt %) and amounts and ratios are on an active ingredient basis, i.e., total weight of benzoate or sorbate salt and the nonionic surfactant. Numbers of polymerized units of propylene oxide or ethylene oxide are number averages.

Preferably, the benzoate or sorbate salt is an alkali metal salt; preferably lithium, sodium or potassium; preferably sodium or potassium. Preferably, the benzoate salt is sodium benzoate. Preferably, the sorbate salt is potassium sorbate. The term “benzoate or sorbate salt” encompasses mixtures of benzoate and sorbate salts.

Preferably, the weight ratio of the nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups to the benzoate salt is from 1:0.5 to 1:100. Preferably, the weight ratio of the nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups to the sorbate salt is from 1:1 to 1:100. Preferably, the weight ratio of the nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups to the sorbate salt is from 1:5 to 1:100.

The present invention is further directed to a method for inhibiting the growth of S. aureus in an aqueous medium by adding: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate or sorbate salt is from 1:2.9982 to 1:109.7646.

The present invention is further directed to a method for inhibiting the growth of mold, preferably A. niger, in an aqueous medium by adding: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate or sorbate salt is from 1:0.12 to 1:13.7143.

The present invention is further directed to a method for inhibiting the growth of S. aureus in an aqueous medium by adding: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate salt is from 1:3.6010 to 1:109.7646; preferably from 1:10.2886 to 1:109.7646.

The present invention is further directed to a method for inhibiting the growth of S. aureus in an aqueous medium by adding: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:2.3990 to 1:109.7646.

The present invention is further directed to a method for inhibiting the growth of mold, preferably A. niger, in an aqueous medium by adding: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R¹O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₅(CH₂CH₂O)₉H

where R¹ is a C₈ alkyl group; and (b) a sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:0.1 to 1:0.9143; preferably from 1:0.1 to 1:0.2857 or 1:0.3429 to 1:0.9143.

The present invention is further directed to an aqueous composition comprising from 5 to 40 wt % of a benzoate or sorbate salt and a nonionic surfactant with structure:

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H

where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups, wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate or sorbate salt is from 1:0.5 to 1:100. In one preferred embodiment, the benzoate or sorbate salt is a benzoate salt and the weight ratio is from 1:0.5 to 1:100. In another preferred embodiment, the benzoate or sorbate salt is a sorbate salt and the weight ratio is from 1:1 to 1:100. Preferably the composition comprises from 5 to 35 wt % of a benzoate or sorbate salt, preferably from 10 to 30 wt %. Preferably, the composition comprises from 20 to 90 wt % water, preferably from 30 to 80 wt %.

The present invention is further directed to an aqueous composition comprising from 25 to 40 wt % of a sorbate salt and a nonionic surfactant with structure: R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups, wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:5 to 1:100. Preferably the composition comprises from 28 to 38 wt % of a sorbate salt, preferably from 30 to 35 wt %. Preferably, the composition comprises from 50 to 75 wt % water, preferably from 55 to 72 wt %.

R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups. Preferably, the C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups comprise from 50 to 85 wt % C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl groups and 15 to 50 wt % C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups, preferably from 60 to 75 wt % C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl groups and 25 to 40 wt % C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups, preferably about 70 wt % C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl groups and about 30 wt % C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups. Preferably, the linear alkyl groups are derived from seed oil.

Preferably, each of the synergistic microbicidal compositions is substantially free of microbicides other than the nonionic surfactant and the sorbate or benzoate salt, i.e., it has less than 1 wt % of microbicides other than the nonionic surfactant and the sorbate or benzoate salt based on total weight of active ingredients, preferably less than 0.5 wt %, preferably less than 0.2 wt %, preferably less than 0.1 wt %. Preferably, when the nonionic surfactant and the sorbate or benzoate salt are added to an aqueous medium, the medium is substantially free of other microbicides, i.e., it has less than 1 wt % of microbicides other than the nonionic surfactant and the sorbate or benzoate salt based on total weight of active ingredients, preferably less than 0.5 wt %, preferably less than 0.2 wt %, preferably less than 0.1 wt %.

The compositions of this invention may contain other ingredients, e.g., defoamers and emulsifiers. The microbicidal compositions of the present invention can be used to inhibit the growth of microorganisms or higher forms of aquatic life (such as protozoans, invertebrates, bryozoans, dinoflagellates, crustaceans, mollusks, etc) by introducing a microbicidally effective amount of the compositions into an aqueous medium subject to microbial attack. Suitable aqueous media are found in, for example: industrial process water; electrocoat deposition systems; cooling towers; air washers; gas scrubbers; mineral slurries; wastewater treatment; ornamental fountains; reverse osmosis filtration; ultrafiltration; ballast water; evaporative condensers; heat exchangers; pulp and paper processing fluids and additives; starch; plastics; emulsions; dispersions; paints; latices; coatings, such as varnishes; construction products, such as mastics, caulks, and sealants; construction adhesives, such as ceramic adhesives, carpet backing adhesives, and laminating adhesives; industrial or consumer adhesives; photographic chemicals; printing fluids; household products, such as bathroom and kitchen cleaners; cosmetics; toiletries; shampoos; soaps; personal care products such as wipes, lotions, sunscreen, conditioners, creams, and other leave-on applications; detergents; industrial cleaners; floor polishes; laundry rinse water; metalworking fluids; conveyor lubricants; hydraulic fluids; leather and leather products; textiles; textile products; wood and wood products, such as plywood, chipboard, flakeboard, laminated beams, oriented strandboard, hardboard, and particleboard; petroleum processing fluids; fuel; oilfield fluids, such as injection water, fracture fluids, and drilling muds; agriculture adjuvant preservation; surfactant preservation; medical devices; diagnostic reagent preservation; food preservation, such as plastic or paper food wrap; food, beverage, and industrial process pasteurizers; toilet bowls; recreational water; pools; and spas.

The specific amount of the microbicidal compositions of this invention necessary to inhibit or control the growth of microorganisms in an application will vary. Typically, the amount of the composition of the present invention is sufficient to control the growth of microorganisms if it provides from 1,000 to 30,000 ppm (parts per million) active ingredients of the composition. It is preferred that the active ingredients (i.e., nonionic surfactant and sorbate or benzoate salt) of the composition be present in the medium to be treated in an amount of at least 2,000 ppm, preferably at least 3,000 ppm, preferably at least 4,000 ppm, preferably at least 6,000 ppm, preferably at least 8,000 ppm. It is preferred that the active ingredients of the composition be present in the locus in an amount of no more than 25,000 ppm, preferably no more than 20,000 ppm, preferably no more than 15,000 ppm, preferably no more than 10,000 ppm, preferably no more than 8,000 ppm. In a method of this invention, a composition is treated to inhibit microbial growth by adding, together or separately, the nonionic surfactant and sorbate or benzoate salt, in amounts that would produce the concentrations indicated above.

Examples

Surfactants and biocides were evaluated for synergy by determining the synergy index (S.I.) of the combination. Synergy index was calculated based on minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC) of two antimicrobial compounds (A and B) alone and in combinations. The tests organisms were Gram negative bacteria (Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC #15442), Gram positive bacteria (Staphylococcus aureus ATCC #6538), yeast (Candida albicans ATCC#10203) and mold (Aspergillus niger ATCC#16404). Contact time for the bacteria was 24 and 48 hours, yeast was 48 and 72 hrs, and 3 and 7 days for mold. The test was carried out in 96 well microtiter plates.

R¹O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₅(CH₂CH₂O)₉H,  Surf. A

where R¹ is 2-ethylhexyl

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H  Surf. D

R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H  Surf. E

In Surf. D and Surf. E, R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups (70% C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl and 30% C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl)

Inoculums Used Inoculum Size of organisms (CFU/ml) Staphylococcus Pseudomonas Aspergillus Candida aureus aeruginosa niger albicans Surfactants ATCC# 6538 ATCC # 15442 ATCC# 16404 ATCC#10203 Surf. A 1.156E+06 8.134E+07 1.156E+06 1.156+06 Surf. D 1.808E+05 1.156E+08 1.156E+06 5.726E+05 Surf. E 1.808E+06 5.727E+07 5.726E+05 1.808E+06

TABLE 4 Media Used Media Used for testing Staphylococcus Pseudomonas Aspergillus Candida aureus aeruginosa niger albicans ATCC# 6538 ATCC # 15442 ATCC# 16404 ATCC#10203 10% Tryptic 10% Tryptic Potato Potato soy broth soy broth dextrose broth dextrose broth

The pH of the Triptic soy broth was 7.3 and the Potato dextrose broth was 5.1

The test results for demonstration of synergy of the MIC combinations are shown in the tables below. Each table shows the results for combinations of two components against the microorganisms tested with incubation times; the end-point activity in ppm measured by the MIC for compound A alone (CA), for component B alone (CB), and the mixture (Ca) and (Cb); the calculated SI value; and the range of synergistic ratios for each combination tested. SI is calculated as follows:

Ca/CA+Cb/CB=Synergy Index (“SI”)

Wherein:

-   -   CA=concentration of compound A in ppm, acting alone, which         produced an end point (MIC of Compound A).     -   Ca=concentration of compound A in ppm, in the mixture, which         produced an end point.     -   CB=concentration of compound B in ppm, acting alone, which         produced an end point (MIC of Compound B).     -   Cb=concentration of compound B in ppm, in the mixture, which         produced an end point.         When the sum of Ca/CA and Cb/CB is greater than one, antagonism         is indicated. When the sum is equal to one, additivity is         indicated, and when less than one, synergism is demonstrated.

The ratio ranges at which sorbate, benzoate and the surfactants were tested are as summarized in the following tables:

Sodium Benzoate with Surf. A Organism ATCC# From To Ratio Range Staphylococcus 6538 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- aureus 1:4.5714 Aspergillus niger 16404 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Candida albicans 10203 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Pseudomonas 15442 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- aeruginosa 1:4.5714

Sodium Benzoate with Surf. E Organism ATCC# From To Ratio Range Staphylococcus 6538 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aureus 1:137.143 Aspergillus niger 16404 0.2:20,000  1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Candida albicans 10203 0.2:20,000  1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Pseudomonas 15442 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aeruginosa 1:137.143

Sodium Benzoate with Surf. D Organism ATCC# From To Ratio Range Staphylococcus 6538 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aureus 1:137.143 Aspergillus niger 16404 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- 1:137.143 Candida albicans 10203 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- 1:137.143 Pseudomonas 15442 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aeruginosa 1:137.143

Potassium Sorbate with Surf. A Organism ATCC# From To Ratio Range Staphylococcus 6538 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- aureus 1:4.5714 Aspergillus niger 16404 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Candida albicans 10203 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Pseudomonas 15442 0.2:20,000 1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- aeruginosa 1:4.5714

Potassium Sorbate with Surf. E Organism ATCC# From To Ratio Range Staphylococcus 6538 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aureus 1:137.143 Aspergillus niger 16404 0.2:20,000  1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Candida albicans 10203 0.2:20,000  1,000:218.75 1:0.00001- 1:4.5714 Pseudomonas 15442 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aeruginosa 1:137.143

Potassium Sorbate with Surf. D Organism ATCC# From To Ratio Range Staphylococcus 6538 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aureus 1:137.143 Aspergillus 16404 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- niger 1:137.143 Candida 10203 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- albicans 1:137.143 Pseudomonas 15442 6.0:20,000 30,000:218.75 1:0.0003- aeruginosa 1:137.143

A: Surf. A B: Sodium Benzoate A. niger ATCC#16404 No Synergy C. albicans ATCC#10203 No Synergy Ps. aeruginosa ATCC#15442 No Synergy S. aureus ATCC# 6538 No Synergy

A: Surf. D B: Sodium Benzoate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 1.156E+06 PPM AI MIC Values (3rd day) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) A. niger 20000 5998 10000 2401 0.90 1:0.2401 ATCC#16404 20000 5998 10000 1801 0.80 1:0.1801 20000 5998 10000 1499 0.75 1:0.1499 20000 5998 10000 1200 0.70 1:0.1200 20000 5998 5000 3000 0.75 1:0.6000 20000 5998 5000 2401 0.65 1:0.4802 20000 5998 5000 1801 0.55 1:0.3602 20000 5998 5000 1499 0.50 1:0.2998 20000 5998 5000 1200 0.45 1:0.2400 20000 5998 2500 3000 0.63 1:1.2000 20000 5998 2500 2401 0.53 1:0.9604 20000 5998 2500 1801 0.43 1:0.7204 20000 5998 2500 1499 0.37 1:0.5996 20000 5998 2500 1200 0.33 1:0.4800 20000 5998 1750 3000 0.59 1:1.7143 20000 5998 1750 2401 0.49 1:1.3720 20000 5998 1750 1801 0.39 1:1.0291 20000 5998 1750 1499 0.34 1:0.8566 20000 5998 437.5 3000 0.52 1:6.8571 20000 5998 437.5 2401 0.42 1:5.4880 20000 5998 437.5 1801 0.32 1:4.1166 20000 5998 437.5 1499 0.27 1:3.4263 20000 5998 218.75 3000 0.51 1:13.7143 20000 5998 218.75 2401 0.41 1:10.9760 20000 5998 218.75 1801 0.31 1:8.2331 20000 5998 218.75 1499 0.26 1:6.8526

A: Surf. D B: Sodium Benzoate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 5.726E+05 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (48 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) C. albicans 20000 1200 2500 899 0.87 1:0.3596 ATCC#10203 20000 1200 1750 600 0.59 1:0.3429 20000 1200 1750 899 0.84 1:0.5137

A: Surf. D B: Sodium Benzoate Ps. aeruginosa ATCC#15442 No Synergy

A: Surf. D B: Sodium Benzoate Media: 1/10 TSB Inoculum size: 1.808E+05 PPM AI MIC Values (24 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) S. aureus 20000 30000 5000 14991 0.75 1:2.9982 ATCC# 20000 30000 1750 14991 0.59 1:8.5663 6538 20000 30000 1750 24011 0.89 1:13.7206 20000 30000 1750 18005 0.69 1:10.2886 20000 30000 875 24011 0.84 1:27.4411 20000 30000 875 18005 0.64 1:20.5771 20000 30000 875 14991 0.54 1:17.1326 20000 30000 437.5 24011 0.82 1:54.8823 20000 30000 437.5 18005 0.62 1:41.1543 20000 30000 437.5 14991 0.52 1:34.2651 20000 30000 218.75 24011 0.81 1:109.7646 20000 30000 218.75 18005 0.61 1:82.3086 20000 30000 218.75 14991 0.51 1:68.5303

A: Surf. E B: Sodium Benzoate A. niger ATCC#16404 No Synergy C. albicans ATCC#10203 No Synergy

A: Surf. E B: Sodium Benzoate Media: 1/10TSB Inoculum size: 5.727E+07 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (48 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) Ps. aeruginosa 20000 14991 437.5 11995 0.82 1:27.4171 ATCC#15442 20000 14991 218.75 11995 0.81 1:54.8343

A: Surf. E B: Sodium benzoate Media: 1/10TSB Inoculum size: 1.808E+06 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (24 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) S. aureus 20000 30000 5000 18005 0.85 1:3.6010 ATCC# 20000 30000 2500 24011 0.93 1:9.6044 6538 20000 30000 1750 24011 0.89 1:13.7206 20000 30000 1750 18005 0.69 1:10.2886 20000 30000 875 24011 0.84 1:27.4411 20000 30000 437.5 24011 0.82 1:54.8823 20000 30000 437.5 18005 0.62 1:41.1543 20000 30000 218.75 24011 0.81 1:109.7646

A: Surf. A B: Potassium Sorbate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 1.156E+06 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (3rd day) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) A. niger 20000 1000 5000 500 0.75 1:0.1000 ATCC#16404 20000 1000 5000 600 0.85 1:0.1200 20000 1000 2500 500 0.63 1:0.2000 20000 1000 2500 600 0.73 1:0.2400 20000 1000 2500 800 0.93 1:0.3200 20000 1000 1750 500 0.59 1:0.2857 20000 1000 1750 600 0.69 1:0.3429 20000 1000 1750 800 0.89 1:0.4571 20000 1000 875 500 0.54 1:0.5714 20000 1000 875 600 0.64 1:0.6857 20000 1000 875 800 0.84 1:0.9143

A: Surf. A B: Potassium Sorbate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 1.156E+06 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (48 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) C. albicans 20000 800 218.75 600 0.76 1:2.7429 ATCC#10203

A: Surf. A B: Potassium Sorbate Ps. aeruginosa ATCC#15442 No Synergy S. aureus ATCC# 6538 No Synergy

A: Surf. D B: Potassium Sorbate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 1.156E+06 PPM AI MIC Values (3rd day) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) A. niger 20000 5998 10000 2401 0.90 1:0.2401 ATCC#16404 20000 5998 10000 1801 0.80 1:0.1801 20000 5998 10000 1499 0.75 1:0.1499 20000 5998 10000 1200 0.70 1:0.1200 20000 5998 5000 3000 0.75 1:0.6000 20000 5998 5000 2401 0.65 1:0.4802 20000 5998 5000 1801 0.55 1:0.3602 20000 5998 5000 1499 0.50 1:0.2998 20000 5998 5000 1200 0.45 1:0.2400 20000 5998 2500 3000 0.63 1:1.2000 20000 5998 2500 2401 0.53 1:0.9604 20000 5998 2500 1801 0.43 1:0.7204 20000 5998 2500 1499 0.37 1:0.5996 20000 5998 2500 1200 0.33 1:0.4800 20000 5998 1750 3000 0.59 1:1.7143 20000 5998 1750 2401 0.49 1:1.3720 20000 5998 1750 1801 0.39 1:1.0291 20000 5998 1750 1499 0.34 1:0.8566 20000 5998 437.5 3000 0.52 1:6.8571 20000 5998 437.5 2401 0.42 1:5.4880 20000 5998 437.5 1801 0.32 1:4.1166 20000 5998 437.5 1499 0.27 1:3.4263 20000 5998 218.75 3000 0.51 1:13.7143 20000 5998 218.75 2401 0.41 1:10.9760 20000 5998 218.75 1801 0.31 1:8.2331 20000 5998 218.75 1499 0.26 1:6.8526

A: Surf. D B: Potassium Sorbate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 5.726E+05 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (48 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) C. albicans 20000 1200 2500 899 0.87 1:0.3596 ATCC#10203 20000 1200 1750 600 0.59 1:0.3429 20000 1200 1750 899 0.84 1:0.5137

A: Surf. D B: Potassium Sorbate Ps. aeruginosa ATCC#15442 No Synergy

A: Surf. D B: Potassium Sorbate Media: 1/10 TSB Inoculum size: 1.808E+05 PPM AI MIC Values (24 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) S. aureus 20000 30000 5000 14991 0.75 1:2.9982 ATCC# 20000 30000 1750 14991 0.59 1:8.5663 6538 20000 30000 1750 24011 0.89 1:13.7206 20000 30000 1750 18005 0.69 1:10.2886 20000 30000 875 24011 0.84 1:27.4411 20000 30000 875 18005 0.64 1:20.5771 20000 30000 875 14991 0.54 1:17.1326 20000 30000 437.5 24011 0.82 1:54.8823 20000 30000 437.5 18005 0.62 1:41.1543 20000 30000 437.5 14991 0.52 1:34.2651 20000 30000 218.75 24011 0.81 1:109.7646 20000 30000 218.75 18005 0.61 1:82.3086 20000 30000 218.75 14991 0.51 1:68.5303

A: Surf. E B: Potassium Sorbate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 1.156E+06 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (3rd day) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) A. niger 20000 1000 5000 600 0.85 1:0.1200 ATCC#16404 20000 1000 2500 800 0.93 1:0.3200

A: Surf. E B: Potassium Sorbate Media: PDB Inoculum size: 1.808E+06 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (48 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) C. albicans 20000 600 5000 300 0.75 1:0.0600 ATCC#10203 20000 600 5000 400 0.92 1:0.0800 20000 600 2500 400 0.79 1:0.1600 20000 600 2500 500 0.96 1:0.2000 20000 600 1750 400 0.75 1:0.2286 20000 600 1750 500 0.92 1:0.2857 20000 600 875 500 0.88 1:0.5714

A: Surf. E B: Potassium Sorbate Media: 1/10TSB Inoculum size: 5.727E+07 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (24 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) Ps. aeruginosa 20000 14991 875 11995 0.84 1:13.7086 ATCC#15442 20000 14991 437.5 11995 0.82 1:27.4171

A: Surf. E B: Potassium Sorbate Media: 1/10TSB Inoculum size: 1.808E+06 CFU/ml PPM AI MIC Values (24 hrs) Test Alone Combination Ratio Organism CA CB Ca Cb S.I. (Ca:Cb) S. aureus 20000 30000 5000 11995 0.65 1:2.3990 ATCC# 20000 30000 5000 14991 0.75 1:2.9982 6538 20000 30000 5000 18005 0.85 1:3.6010 20000 30000 2500 11995 0.52 1:4.7980 20000 30000 2500 14991 0.62 1:5.9964 20000 30000 2500 18005 0.73 1:7.2020 20000 30000 2500 24011 0.93 1:9.6044 20000 30000 1750 11995 0.49 1:6.8543 20000 30000 1750 14991 0.59 1:8.5663 20000 30000 1750 18005 0.69 1:10.2886 20000 30000 1750 24011 0.89 1:13.7206 20000 30000 875 11995 0.44 1:13.7086 20000 30000 875 14991 0.54 1:17.1326 20000 30000 875 18005 0.64 1:20.5771 20000 30000 875 24011 0.84 1:27.4411 20000 30000 437.5 14991 0.52 1:34.2651 20000 30000 437.5 18005 0.62 1:41.1543 20000 30000 437.5 24011 0.82 1:54.8823 20000 30000 218.75 14991 0.51 1:68.5303 20000 30000 218.75 18005 0.61 1:82.3086 20000 30000 218.75 24011 0.81 1:109.7646

The following biocides had no synergy against any organism tested when paired with the following surfactants:

Surf. A

Sodium Benzoate, TRIS NITRO

Surf. E

DMDMH

Surf. D

CS-1246, OPP, DMDMH

In the following combinations, the ratio of surfactant to biocide where synergy was observed were not commercially relevant, i.e., a ratio of 1:0.2 or greater (less biocide relative to surfactant). At these ratios, the biocide levels in a formulated product would be too low to be practical: Surf. A

DIDAC, IPBC

Surf. E

CMIT/MIT, IPBC, OIT, TTPC, WSCP

Surf. D

CMIT/MIT, OIT, DIDAC

(MBIT, IPBC, WSCP were synergistic only at 1:0.05 or worse except for one data point)

Stability Testing

A solution of sodium benzoate or potassium sorbate in water was made and diluted with surfactant to give the desired ratios of biocide to surfactant. Additional water was added as needed to give the indicate wt % solutions. The samples were split into three vials. One vial was stored at room temperature, one was stored at 40° C. and one was stored at 50° C. Samples were evaluated after a week to determine stability. Samples that were cloudy or highly discolored were determined to be unstable. In the data tables, a dash indicates that the formulation was stable.

Stability Data-10% Sodium benzoate in combination with Surfactants- Day 1 Surfac- Temperature tant:Sodium Room Surfactant benzoate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:27 — — — 1:10 — — — Surf. B 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:10 — — — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:10 — — — cocoampho- 1:27 — — — diacetate 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — Cloudy L-62 1:27 — Slightly Cloudy cloudy 1:100 — Slightly Slightly cloudy cloudy TERGITOL 1:10 Slightly Slightly Cloudy 81 cloudy cloudy 1:27 Slightly Slightly Cloudy cloudy cloudy 1:100 — — Slightly cloudy TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — * Surf. B is R¹O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₅(CH₂CH₂O)₆H, where R¹ is 2-ethylhexyl

Stability Data-10% Sodium benzoate in combination with Surfactants- Day 2 Surfac- Temperature tant:Sodium Room Surfactant benzoate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:27 — — — 1:10 — — — Surf. B 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:10 — — — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:10 — — — cocoampho- 1:27 — — — diacetate 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — Cloudy L-62 1:27 — Slightly Cloudy cloudy 1:100 — Slightly Slightly cloudy cloudy TERGITOL 1:10 Slightly Slightly Cloudy + 81 cloudy cloudy white precipitate 1:27 Slightly Slightly Cloudy + cloudy cloudy white precipitate 1:100 — — Slightly cloudy + white precipitate TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — —

Stability Data-10% Sodium benzoate in combination with Surfactants- Day 7 Surfac- Temperature tant:Sodium Room Surfactant benzoate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:27 — — — 1:10 — — — Surf. B 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:10 — — — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:10 — — — cocoampho- 1:27 — — — diacetate 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — Cloudy L-62 1:27 — Slightly Cloudy cloudy 1:100 — Slightly Slightly cloudy cloudy TERGITOL 1:10 Slightly Cloudy Cloudy 81 cloudy 1:27 Slightly Cloudy Cloudy cloudy 1:100 — Slightly Slightly cloudy cloudy TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — —

Stability Data-30% Sodium benzoate in combination with Surfactants- Day 1 Surfac- Temperature tant:Sodium Room Surfactant benzoate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:27 — — — 1:10 — — — Surf. B 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:10 — — — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:10 — — — cocoampho- 1:27 — — — diacetate 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — — L-61 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 81 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — —

Stability Data-30% Sodium benzoate in combination with Surfactants- Day 2 Surfac- Temperature tant:Sodium Room Surfactant benzoate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:27 — — — 1:10 — — — Surf. B 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:10 — — — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:10 — — — cocoampho- 1:27 — — — diacetate 1:100 — — — Tergitol 1:10 — — — L-61 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 81 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — —

Stability Data-30% Sodium benzoate in combination with Surfactants- Day 7 Surfac- Temperature tant:Sodium Room Surfactant benzoate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:27 — — — 1:10 — — — Surf. B 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:10 — — — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:10 — — — cocoampho- 1:27 — — — diacetate 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — White L-61 solid 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — White 81 precipitate 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:10 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:100 — — —

Stability Data-33% Potassium sorbate in combination with Surfactants- Day 3 Surfac- Temperature tant:Potassium Room Surfactant sorbate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:1 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. A 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — Surf. B 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:1 — — — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:1 White White White cocoampho- precipitate precipitate precipitate diacetate 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:1 — — — L-62 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — TERGITOL 1:1 — — — 81 1:27 — Cloudy — 1:68 — Cloudy Cloudy 1:100 — — Cloudy TERGITOL 1:1 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Note: All Room Temperature and 40° C. samples were a light yellow color unless noted, and all 50° C. samples were dark yellow unless noted.

Stability Data—33% Potassium sorbate in combination with Surfactants- Day 7 Surfac- Temperature tant:Potassium Room Surfactant sorbate Temperature 40° C. 50° C. Surf. D 1:1 — — Brown solid 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. E 1:5 — — — 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Surf. A 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — Surf. B 1:0.5 — — — 1:27 — — — POLYSOR- 1:1 — Amber — BATE 20 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Disodium 1:1 White White Brown cocoampho- precipitate precipitate solid diacetate 1:27 — Amber — 1:68 — Amber — 1:100 — Amber — TERGITOL 1:1 — — Brown L-62 solid 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Tergitol 1:1 — — Brown solid 81 1:27 — cloudy — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Tergitol 1:1 — — — 15-S-7 1:27 — — — 1:68 — — — 1:100 — — — Note: All Room Temperature were a light yellow color unless noted, all 40° C. samples were dark yellow unless noted, and all 50° C. samples were amber unless noted. 

1. A synergistic microbicidal composition comprising: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure: R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate or sorbate salt is from 1:0.12 to 1:109.7646.
 2. The synergistic microbicidal composition of claim 1 in which said mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups comprises from 60 to 75 wt % C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl groups and 25 to 40 wt % C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups.
 3. A method for inhibiting the growth of microorganisms in an aqueous medium; said method comprising adding to said aqueous medium: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure: R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₅H where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate or sorbate salt is from 1:0.12 to 1:109.7646.
 4. The method of claim 3 in which said mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups comprises from 60 to 75 wt % C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl groups and 25 to 40 wt % C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups.
 5. A synergistic microbicidal composition comprising: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure: R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate salt is from 1:3.6010 to 1:109.7646 and a ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:0.06 to 1:0.5714 or 1:2.3990 to 1:109.7646.
 6. The synergistic microbicidal composition of claim 5 in which said mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups comprises from 60 to 75 wt % C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl groups and 25 to 40 wt % C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups.
 7. A method for inhibiting the growth of microorganisms in an aqueous medium; said method comprising adding to said aqueous medium: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure: R²O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₃(CH₂CH₂O)₇H where R² is a mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups; and (b) a benzoate or sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the benzoate salt is from 1:3.6010 to 1:109.7646 and a ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:0.06 to 1:0.5714 or 1:2.3990 to 1:109.7646.
 8. The method of claim 7 in which said mixture of C₈-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups comprises from 60 to 75 wt % C₈-C₁₀ linear alkyl groups and 25 to 40 wt % C₁₂-C₁₄ linear alkyl groups.
 9. A synergistic microbicidal composition comprising: (a) a nonionic surfactant with structure: R¹O(CH₂CH(CH₃)O)₅(CH₂CH₂O)₉H where R¹ is a C₈ alkyl group; and (b) a sorbate salt; wherein a weight ratio of said nonionic surfactant to the sorbate salt is from 1:0.1 to 1:0.9143.
 10. The synergistic microbicidal composition of claim 9 in which, said C₈ alkyl group is a 2-ethylhexyl group. 